Online ordering powered by Seamless
654 9TH AVE (9th Ave. & 46th St.)(212) 262-6767
Minimum order of $12.00 is required for delivery
Delivery estimate is 25 - 40 min (more info)
Unfortunately, Cara Mia is not open at the delivery/pickup time that you selected. Please make sure that you've entered an address and try changing the time in the Order Information section to the right.
Seamless allows you to enjoy convenient online ordering from the best local restaurants. If you're ordering for the first time, start your order by entering your address to the right. Return users log in here.
Print this menu
Cara Mia restaurant is located in the heart of the Theater District, just a few steps away from Times Square. Since 1997, Cara Mia has offered its customers delicious and creative Italian cuisine, specializing in homemade pastas as well as a variety of meats and seafood.
Read more
Cara Mia also features a magical combination of excellent Italian cuisine and the finest wine selection. The finest pasta, seafood, and meats are served up by very talented waiters. This 75-seat-restaurant is located off the corner of Restaurant Row, and features cozy brick walls decorated with stills from Italian Holiday and photographs of Italian celebrities.
Hide
Antipasto Misto—An array of Italian cold cuts and cheeses, artichokes, peppers and olives
Fusilli Del Bosco—Broccoli rabe, sausage and tomato
Cannelloni—Baked with spinach and ricotta in an aurora sauce
Risotto Alla Pescatore—Arborio rice with shrimp, calamari and clams in a spicy tomato sauce
Scaloppine Marsala—Veal sautéed with mixed mushrooms and Sicilian Marsala wine
Crème Brulee—With a zest of orange, lemon and lime
Disastrous! Over an hour for delivery and i live 1 block away. The food was so over cooked the risotto was mush and the seafood was so rubbery it was completely inedible. Actually debated about going through the hassle of returning it. working in a restaurant for most of my life i would like to think this was just an off night but no respectful place would have put that out the door
Posted 2 weeks ago by ryan h.
25-40 minutes? Not even close. It took them 1 hour and 25 minutes. Food is not good either.
Posted 2 months ago by Jae L.
good delivery; excellent flavor and quantity.
Posted 4 months ago by Varun D.
get the chicken parm!!!
Posted 7 months ago by Thomas A.
I ordered the boar and it was way too much meat and way too greasy. Maybe the "regular" dishes are better. But I won't be finding out.
Posted 8 months ago by Stephen W.
Terrific italian, semi-high end, but totally worth the price. Consistent, delicious, and always quick.
Posted 9 months ago by Erick B.
this place is not good - there was so much salt in the spaghetti ala margherita it was seriously inedible. my coworker got the risotto alla pescatore and it was incredibly bland and flavorless. i'm not sure if the accidentally doubled the seasoning for dish and left out hers but we will not be ordering from this place again. two stars because the food did arrive on time and the salmone alla grigia was decent.
Posted 11 months ago by Vicky Y.
Always fresh, tasty, and delicious Italian Food. Only wish they delivered faster!
Posted a year ago by Andrew H.
I used to order only the risotto primavera, which I loved. And now they deleted only this item, I guess they got sick of my single item order. Shame on you Cara Mia owners!
Posted a year ago by Marcio C.
worst service ever. they dont update their menu either.
Posted a year ago by Dara K.
Pasta was fine but a dried out piece of salmon after an hour and 25 minute wait really wasn't what I was hoping for....
Posted a year ago by Karen P.
Food is great, but agree that the delivery is consistently LONG. Just wanted to make orderers aware. Worth the wait usually though.
Posted a year ago by Paul B.
The consistency of the tortellini in the tortellini al nonna was a bit gritty, which was a gross combination with the cream sauce, but the taste of it combined with everything else was good.
Posted 2 years ago by Akilah R.
Food is excellent; however, delivery takes 1 hour to 1 hour and 45 minutes; it would be fine if they stated up front that the timeline would be this long, however, they say "25-40 minutes". I have now ordered 10-15 times from them, and it has never been delivered within 45 minutes of the estimated time.
Posted 2 years ago by R. Elliott T.
Yum! The calamari was excellent. Will definitely be ordering from here again.
Posted 2 years ago by Rebecca M.
First order has been of excellent quality. Will surely return for more.
Posted 4 years ago by Stefan Z.
Only select user reviews are published on Seamless. All user-submitted ratings contribute to Cara Mia's overall Seamless rating, but we manually screen all reviews and only publish those that are relevant and helpful. Tips for getting your review published »
Above content provided by restaurant.
Order online from Cara Mia by entering your address below. Online ordering powered by Seamless.com.
Return users log in here.
Click a menu item to add it to your order.
Back to top